Blogopmaak

By Gideon Gort

Five extermination camps were created by the Nazis, all located in Poland. Don't confuse these camps with the concentration camps. The extermination camps only had one purpose: the killing of people. Concentration camps were developed to detain people which the Nazis wanted to exclude from society. Jews, intellectuals, Poles, you name it. Everyone the Nazis didn't trust were sent to those camps for forced labor and to exclude them from daily life. The fact that many of these people died was a warm welcome for the Nazis (the Nazis killed them by starvation and exhaustion). But the concentration camps were not built for the mass murder of people.


In our Holocaust story
The Holocaust Explained we told you about the killing by the Einsatzgruppen. But a faster method was needed because there were 11 million Jews to kill. Bring the victims to their killers instead of the killers to the victims.


The Final Solution, the murder of all European Jews, was decided by Reinhard Heydrich (head of the RSHA, Reichssicherheitshauptamt or Reich security main office) and
Heinrich Himmler (the Reichsfuhrer SS and second most powerful man in the Third Reich). The first extermination camp was Chełmno (1941), Auschwitz-Birkenau was the second one (it was in the beginning an concentration camp, later also an extermination camp). Bełżec, Sobibór and Treblinka opened in 1942 were specially developed to kill the Jews in the General-Government (an occupied territory in Poland).


Why is Auschwitz-Birkenau known by almost every person in the (Western) World? And why is Bełżec unknown to almost everybody we speak to?


First take a look at the names of the extermination camps.

Chełmno, hard to pronounce, was called Kulmhof by the Nazis.

Oświęcim and Brzezinka had the same problem for the Nazis, so they made it easier for themselves: Auschwitz-Birkenau. 

Bełżec, Sobibór and Treblinka are the Polish version, but without the accent marks the Nazis used the same names. 


Auschwitz-Birkenau the largest in surface and death toll was an extermination camp but also a concentration camp.

It was liberated on 26 Januari 1945 by the Red Army (Soviet Union) and had a lot of survivors due the fact that it had a double function. Also the fact that there were a lot of children among them makes it interesting. Those children told us, up to 80 years later, the story of their life inside Auschwitz-Birkenau. They are the living witnesses. Also a lot of other survivors gave us testimonials. For example, Filip Müller, a member of the Sonderkommando (special commando to burn the bodies), wrote his story in a very interesting testimony about the gas chambers in Auschwitz-Birkenau. Because a lot of transports from the west were sent to Auschwitz-Birkenau, more interest was created in education and at schools in Western Europe. The fact that Auschwitz-Birkenau has ruins (still visible today: ruins of crematoria, gas chambers, barracks and mass graves), survived the war and is situated close to the city's Katowice and Krakow makes it easy to visit. 

In total the Nazis killed more than 1,1 million people in Auschwitz-Birkenau. 


When we take a look at Bełżec there are only two known testimonials from survivors. In Bełżec the Nazis murdered about 434,508 men, women and children between March and December 1942 in the gas chambers. The bodies were dumped in mass graves, from October 1942 the Nazis started to burn the bodies in open pits. In spring 1943 this extermination camp was dismantled, the bodies exhumed and burned. So, almost no survivors, far away in the east (nowadays close to the border of Ukraine) and completely dismantled by the Nazis. It is one of the explanations why this extermination camp is very unknown. 


Sobibór is more famous, especially in Holland. From Westerbork, a transit camp in the northern part of Holland, many transports were sent to Sobibór and Auschwitz-Birkenau. Also the fact that Jules Schelvis, a Dutch survivor, wrote his testimonies, makes Sobibór more famous than Bełżec. At least 34000 Dutch Jews were killed in Sobibór and a total of 150,000 and up to 170,000 in total. Sobibór is a very isolated place. We even got lost when we visited this extermination camp. No tourists, no signs and in 2011 the museum was out of money and had to close the doors. In 2020 the new museum was reopened. That will never happen to Auschwitz-Birkenau with more than a million visitors a year! Sobibor was dismantled in 1944. The area was planted with a pine forest. 


Chełmno, the first extermination camp. We wrote a blog about this place. 

Our visit was very impressive. Read the blog and information about his extermination camp here


Then Treblinka 2 (Treblinka 1 was a labor camp closeby, Treblinka 2 was the extermination camp. But we call Treblinka 2 just Treblinka). The reason why there were “only” 900,000* people murdered is the chilling fact that there were no more Jews to kill. Treblinka was a masterpiece based on the experience first from Bełżec and later from Sobibór.

Treblinka was a small but very efficient killing machine. There were days that 15,000 men, women and children were killed in 24 hours. A stunning number. Testimonies from Franz Suchomel, a Nazi who was based in Treblinka, and from Richard Glazar, a Jew who worked in Treblinka, gave us this number. Treblinka had the capacity to kill at least double the amount of victims, and when the situation was there, we believe it could handle a number above 3 million. 


*In our story The Holocaust explained we talk about 800,000 but more likely 900,000 victims. Till this day the exact number is unknown. Reliable sources such as the Holocaust Encyclopedia from the US Holocaust Memorial Museum mention 925,000 victims. Yad Vashem, The World Holocaust Remembrance Centre in Jerusalem, says 870,000 victims. And many books that we have studied are between 800,000 and some up to a million. 900,000 is an average that we think is a manageable number. We saw this number also at the Treblinka museum.

This situation is also representative for Sobibór, Chełmno and Auschwitz-Birkenau. We simply don't know the exact number of victims. Only the report of Bełżec, 434,508 victims, is very reliable due to a very interesting piece of evidence: the Höfle telegram. 

More about this subject in a new blog. 



Chełmno, Bełżec, Sobibór and Treblinka had no crematorium and no chimneys. Out of five extermination camps, Auschwitz-Birkenau is the only one which had crematoriums and chimneys. In Chełmno, Bełżec, Sobibór and Treblinka bodies were dumped into mass graves and later exhumed and burned in open-air pits. 


Photo: The ruins of crematorium V at Auschwitz-Birkenau. Gideon Gort 2023. 

In Chełmno the Nazis used carbon monoxide from lorries to kill their victims. The carbon monoxide was led into the truck (where the victims were locked up) with a hose directly from the exhaust pipe.

In Bełżec, Sobibór and Treblinka the Nazis used carbon monoxide which came from tank engines which were outside the gas chambers. With pipes the exhaust gasses were led into the gas chambers.

In Auschwitz-Birkenau Zyklon-B was used. A pesticide to delouse clothes and other materials. It was thrown into the gas chambers from hatches in the roof (they were small pellets) and as soon as it came into contact with air the gas was released.


Photo: The place where the massive monument rises. That is the place where the gas chambers were situated at Treblinka. Gideon Gort 2023. 

One man was responsible for the mass murders at Bełżec, Sobibór and Treblinka: Christian Wirth. He invented the method to use carbon monoxide from tank engines. Even offers from Berlin to use Zyklon B were refused by Wirth. He was so proud of his method and it was such an efficient idea that he became “Inspector of the extermination camps Bełżec, Sobibór and Treblinka” after his first role as commander of Bełżec. But he was a beast. Testimonies even from his superiors and Franz Stangl (camp commander at Treblinka) were that he was a devil. He talked so horribly about his victims that his SS-colleagues feared for him. He was always aggressive, vulgar and he was terrible against his own men. Testimonies from Stangl in his memories written by Gitta Sereny: “When I arrived at the gas chamber Wirth wiped the sweat out of his face and was cursing. Later he showed up in a gas chamber which was finished building. He shouted “Let's test this gas chamber with those Jews over there”. Stangl continued: “He was like the devil and with his whip he hit his own men because everything went too slow for him. The doors of the gas chambers were not working properly, so that made him furious.”


Hitler, Himmler and Heydrich were the key figures of the Holocaust. But they did it behind a desk, far away from the terror in Poland. Wirth is in our opinion the keyplayer and directly responsible for the death of at least 1,7 million men, women and children during Aktion Reinhard


Photo: Yad Vashem online archive. 

  • Auschwitz-Birkenau

    Barraks at  Birkenau, Auschwitz  is 2 km to the south. 

    Knop
  • Birkenau site

    Behind us there were hundreds of visitors. They have more interest in the ruins of crematoruim 2 and the selection platform. 

    Knop
  • A ruin of a barrack

    Photo taken from the path that directly led to the gas chambers at crematorium V. 

    Knop

Cans used to store Zyklon B at Auschwitz-Birkenau. When the gas was needed the Nazis openend the can (with a gas mask) and threw the pellets Zyklon B inside the gas chamber via a hatch in the ceiling. 


Photo taken at Auschwitz-Birkenau museum. Gideon Gort 2023.



References:


Stephan Lehnstaedt, De kern van de Holocaust.

USHMM online encyclopedia.

Het Auschwitz Album, Yad Vashem, uitgeverij Verbum.

Filip Müller, Sonderbehandlung.

Kamp Westerbork website. 

Testimony by Franz Suchomel in Shoah, a film by Claude Lanzmann from 1985.

Globus en de Holocaust, by Roelof Manssen.

Yadvashem.org

Stephan Lehnstaedt, Vernietigingskamp Sobibór.

Richard Glazar, Ontsnapt uit Treblinka.

Gitta Sereny, De duisternis tegemoet.

Own visit and research at Museum Chełmno (Kulmhof) (2023), Museum Treblinka (2023), Sobibór (2018) and Museum Auschwitz-Birkenau (2015,2018,2023).

Read about our journeys in our blogs

This is our Explore Diary
door jimmy 08 mrt, 2024
In the long row behind "wait for me, daddy"
door tjarco 21 feb, 2024
“To whom it may concern” A story about my grandfather
door jimmy 14 feb, 2024
The Ireland brothers in arms
door Gideon Gort 04 feb, 2024
By Gideon Gort
door tjarco 22 jan, 2024
History around the corner
door jimmy 14 jan, 2024
The story of John William Stephens
door tjarco 25 dec, 2023
The weight of four flags
door Gideon Gort 19 dec, 2023
Aktion Erntefest By Gideon Gort
door Gideon Gort 13 dec, 2023
The transports to death By Gideon Gort
door gideon 03 dec, 2023
Chelmno the first extermination camp By Gideon Gort
Meer posts
Share by: